A Tale of Two COPs

Cristina Jorda Kinney

|

November 23, 2021

image1

I was one of the lucky ones: I attended the Conference of the Parties in Glasgow (COP26) this month. The conference was held as the world continues to fight the COVID-19 pandemic and moves into an endemic. I acknowledge my privilege, being able to attend a 40,000 person conference overseas, fully vaccinated (including a booster shot), while many millions still don’t have access to a first dose of the COVID-19 vaccine and had to face the tough choice of attending the event and putting their health at risk, or needing to stay home and not being able to fully participate.

Much has been written about the negotiations and the final agreement that was signed after two long weeks of late nights. I don’t have much to add to this that hasn’t already been said.

But I did want to share an experience that perhaps encases quite perfectly my impressions about this process and supports what has been said about the lack of representation of frontline voices in the COP discussions, with youth and BIPOC communities being hugely impactful in the streets, but often barred from the policy discussions. One of the evenings, a select group of us gathered at a beautiful venue in Glasgow to learn more about climate governance, a private event with a noticeable lack of diversity. The High Level Climate Action Champion for UN climate talks during COP26 appointed by the UK government was one of the speakers. I will admit that during his presentation, I drank the Kool-Aid. “If we view our progress as a still picture,” he said, “it’s easy to get disheartened, but as a movie, the storyline shows encouraging progress and hope.” Now, I am all for seeing the positive side of any situation, so it’s no surprise that I found myself nodding my head in agreement. He continued by sharing another accomplishment for COP, being the first to have dedicated days focusing on specific issue areas (transportation, methane, etc.). That seemed like a good way to structure the conference, I thought. More nods from the audience. He went on to describe the great transformation in the electric vehicle (EV) sector and how much momentum there is behind this industry. You get the picture. By the end of the presentations, it was easy to feel hopeful and optimistic.

As the panel opened for Q+A, one of the audience members was clearly eager to be the first to speak and ask a question (I am never that person). She got up, a petite woman of color from South Africa, Executive Director for the Climate Action Network. She opened up her remarks by saying: “I don’t want to be that person, but I am going to be; I often have to be…” What came next was one of the most impactful, thoughtful and truthful remarks I have heard. Delivered with the utmost respect to the panelists and those in attendance, she called them out for being so disconnected from reality, not once mentioning poverty, inequities and disparities in their presentation. Talking about EV’s was just an example of this disconnect at COP, when so many countries in the Global South don’t even have roads, much less EV’s, and people face daily life and death situations caused by climate. For the next 5 to 10 minutes, she spoke the truth that was never acknowledged by the speakers. Her bravery made me feel ashamed. Ashamed that she had to be the one to stand up and share this painful reality (as she probably has had too many times before) to make sure it was not once more dismissed. As I approached her to commend her for her speech and courage, she was still visibly shaken, but hopefully comforted by the warm applause from the room.

This juxtaposition was COP26: on the one hand, a group of leaders, mostly men, negotiated the fate of our future and praised our progress; on the other hand, the voices of civil society and youth, those who are and will continue to be most impacted by inaction, were restricted or denied access,  and their unique and valuable perspectives unheard. And when you leave these important voices out of the conversation, you miss out on arguments that are crucial to make informed decisions. That was the vast disconnect at COP26. Let’s hope we can learn from these mistakes and avoid them in Egypt at next year’s COP.

Email Signature Staff Headshot Template (6)

Cristina Jorda Kinney

Director of Institutional Philanthropy

Cristina is the Director of Institutional Philanthropy and is responsible for designing, developing and implementing ACE’s institutional fundraising program and helping build critical relationships. She holds a JD from Spain and brings over 13 years of experience in the environmental field. In her free time, she enjoys spending time with her family, is an avid hiker, and enjoys photography and traveling as much as possible.

More Blog Posts

IE+Bio+Pic2

ACE INTERVIEW: Philip Aiken on Being an Environmentalist in the Digital Space

Philip Aiken hosts the eco podcast ‘just to save the world.’ He is an environmentalist, creative and a community organizer in Austin, Texas with a background in Engineering and a Masters degree in Renewable Energy. Phil is currently a videographer working with sustainable brands and environmental organizations, a prominent eco TikToker, and founding member and director of media production at Intersectional Environmentalist 501 (c)(3).

Read More
Screen Shot 2021-09-22 at 1.16.15 PM

Wildfires and Climate Change 101

It’s natural for the occasional wildfire to blaze through the US – particularly in drought prone-areas like the Southwest. What is unusual is that these wildfires seem to be occurring more frequently, more ferociously and beyond the usual fire season. So why is this happening?

Read More
image1

“We can’t let this moment become another powerless gesture!”

A panel featuring BIPOC leaders from the US ACE Coalition, was the first event I attended at this year’s United Nations Climate Change conference and proved to resonate with my entire COP26 experience. 

Read More
View More